2023 · 英语(二)· Text 1

塑料草坪争议

塑料草坪因破坏环境和生物多样性而遭到园艺组织与环保人士反对,但支持者提出天然草坪同样消耗资源,英国政府最终选择在现有规则下引导使用者作出更可持续的选择,而不是直接立法禁止。

篇章路线

先看文章怎么展开

1

第1段:提出争议

追求“完美草坪”的捷径可能让环境付出代价,文章由此引出英国皇家园艺学会禁止使用塑料草坪的决定。

2

第2段:解释反对理由

英国皇家园艺学会进一步说明真草的环境效益:支持野生生物、缓解积水并降低环境温度。

3

第3段:补充社会行动

环保人士通过社交媒体和请愿推动禁售塑料草坪,或对其征收生态损害税。

4

第4段:呈现反方观点

塑料草坪行业指出,天然草坪同样需要水、电、汽油、除草剂和其他养护措施,塑料草坪争议并非只有单一立场。

5

第5—6段:给出政府立场

政府不准备全面禁止塑料草坪,但要求相关使用行为符合保护生物多样性和可持续排水的现行规则。

查看全文段间逻辑

文章按照“提出问题—说明反对理由—展示社会行动—补充反方观点—给出政府回应”推进,并不是简单论证“塑料草坪一定错误”。

第4段开头的 `However` 是全文最重要的立场转折:文章开始呈现支持塑料草坪一方的理由。第6段的 `rather than` 则划清了政府“引导选择”和“直接立法”之间的界限。理解这两个转折点,才能看清文章如何从环保组织的反对意见推进到政府的折中立场。

逐句精读

先读原句,再打开讲解

加粗词是本句重点词。每句话默认只展开核心主干,完整分析由你决定什么时候看。

01

第1段

In the quest for the perfect lawn, homeowners across the country are taking a shortcut - and it is the environment that is paying the price. About eight million square metres of plastic grass is sold each year but opposition has now spread to the highest gardening circles. The Chelsea Flower Show has banned fake grass from this year's event, declaring it to be not part of its ethos. The Royal Horticultural Society (RHS), which runs the annual show in west London, says it has introduced the ban because of the damage plastic grass does to the environment and biodiversity.

02

第2段

Ed Horne, of the RHS, said: "We launched our sustainability strategy last year and fake grass is just not in line with our ethos and views on plastic. We recommend using real grass because of its environmental benefits, which include supporting wildlife, alleviating flooding and cooling the environment."

03

第3段

The RHS's decision comes as campaigners try to raise awareness of the problems fake grass causes. A Twitter account, which claims to "cut through the greenwash" of artificial grass, already has more than 20,000 followers. It is trying to encourage people to sign two petitions, one calling for a ban on the sale of plastic grass and another calling for an "ecological damage" tax on such lawns. They have gathered 7,276 and 11,282 signatures.

04

第4段

However, supporters of fake grass point out that there is also an environmental impact with natural lawns, which need mowing and therefore usually consume electricity or petrol. The industry also points out that real grass requires considerable amounts of water, weed killer or other treatments and that people who lay fake grass tend to use their garden more. The industry also claims that people who lay fake grass spend an average of £500 on trees or shrubs for their garden, which provides habitat for insects.

05

第5段

In response to another petition last year about banning fake lawns, which gathered 30,000 signatures, the government responded that it has "no plans to ban the use of artificial grass."

06

第6段

It added: "We prefer to help people and organizations make the right choice rather than legislating on such matters. However, the use of artificial grass must comply with the legal and policy safeguards in place to protect biodiversity and ensure sustainable drainage, while measures such as the strengthened biodiversity duty should serve to encourage public authorities to consider sustainable alternatives."

读完再做

Text 1 真题检验

每道题选择后立即核对答案,再结合解析回到原文深度理解。

21. The RHS thinks that plastic grass __________.

22. The petitions mentioned in Paragraph 3 reveal the campaigners' __________.

23. In Paragraph 4, supporters of fake grass point out __________.

24. What would the government do with regard to artificial grass?

25. It can be learned from the text that fake grass __________.

反馈/建议